TabSphere journal / Ecommerce and digital products
Etsy, Shopify or a custom shop: a practical buyer guide for Scottish small businesses
How to choose between Etsy, Shopify or a bespoke online shop: compliance checks, what to prepare and how to compare quotes for a Scottish seller.

Overview: three routes and the shared rules
You have three common choices: sell through a marketplace (Etsy), use a hosted ecommerce platform (Shopify) or commission a custom shop on your own domain. Legally and practically, the basic obligations, clear pricing, delivery and returns information, product safety and tax registrations, apply regardless of channel. Government guidance on distance selling and unfair commercial practices explains the consumer information you must show at point of sale, and separate platform rules now require platforms to collect and sometimes report seller identity and tax details to HMRC. Treat these shared requirements as the minimum baseline when comparing options. (Facts: consumer and platform rules.)
Practical implication: any quote or platform you consider must be able to display required consumer information, handle VAT where relevant, let you export sales data for accounting and, if you serve Scottish remote postcodes, apply appropriate delivery rules. 1 3
What each option involves, quick differences
Marketplace (Etsy): quick to start, built‑in audience and platform tools, but marketplaces often collect seller identity data and may report to tax authorities under digital platform rules. You will usually be subject to the marketplace’s fees and policies; check who is the seller of record for tax and reporting. (Facts: platform reporting obligations.)
Hosted platform (Shopify): you control pricing and customer experience more than on a marketplace, but you pay monthly platform fees, third‑party app costs and are typically the seller of record responsible for tax and compliance. Hosted stores normally provide admin exports, but verify the format and fields before committing. (Facts: seller responsibilities and data export needs.)
Custom shop: higher upfront cost and longer delivery time but maximum control, useful if you need bespoke checkout rules (age checks, complex shipping rules for the Highlands and islands) or specific integrations with your accounts or stock systems. You will still be the seller of record and must meet consumer‑law disclosure rules. (Facts: same legal duties across channels; logistics in Scotland can be different.) 3 5
Prepare this checklist before you ask for quotes
Create a one‑page brief to include: legal business name, registered address, tax identifier (UTR or company number), contact details; product list with variants; estimated monthly order volume; shipping destinations and preferred carriers (note any Highlands/islands postcodes); whether products are age‑restricted or require safety certificates; desired sales channels (Etsy, Shopify, direct); and accountant/export requirements for orders and invoices. Government guidance and platform rules make many of these items unavoidable during onboarding, so having them ready speeds quotes and avoids scope gaps.
Ask suppliers to break down quotes into design, platform licences, bespoke development hours, integrations, hosting and a 12‑month maintenance estimate, and to state who will appear as seller of record and how data can be exported. 3 5
How to compare quotes, a simple scoring framework
Score each quote on five dimensions: 1) completeness (does the scope match your checklist?), 2) total 12‑month cost (platform fees + apps + hosting + maintenance), 3) compliance capability (can the build show required consumer information, VAT, returns and age checks?), 4) data access (can you export orders, customer details and product lists in useful formats?), 5) delivery logic (can shipping rules handle Scottish remote postcodes and carrier surcharges?). Ask each supplier to confirm, in writing, who will be the seller of record and whether the platform will collect or report your tax identity. Weight the dimensions to reflect what matters to you: low upfront cost vs control and long‑term mobility.
When comparing, watch for missing recurring fees (apps, payment gateway fees) and for vague promises about data access, insist on example export formats or screenshots of admin screens. 1 3 5
A short practical task to try this week
Do a 60‑minute briefing exercise: draft the one‑page brief above, identify three sample product SKUs with prices and weights, and pick three Highland/island postcodes you plan to serve. Then contact your local Trading Standards or council business support to ask about any free product‑safety or selling‑online courses available locally. Use the brief to request line‑by‑line quotes from one marketplace listing (create an Etsy seller draft), one Shopify developer and one web agency offering a custom shop. Compare the responses against the five scoring dimensions and note any missing information to chase up.
This task exposes the practical gaps suppliers often miss and helps you see the real difference between quick marketplace onboarding and a tailored custom shop. 6 3
Final practical tips
Keep copies of any identity/tax documents you submit to platforms and timestamp them. If you expect VATable turnover, tell suppliers up front so VAT can be shown correctly in the checkout and invoices. Factor Scottish delivery complexity into both customer messaging and your quotes. Treat logistical and reporting controls as non‑optional features when comparing long‑term costs.
If you’d like to discuss a website, ecommerce strategy or a practical brief for quotes, we can review your one‑page brief and the supplier responses to help you compare options more confidently. 1 3 6
Sources
Checked 2026-11-06.
